Skip to content
Resilic Logo
  • Solutions
        • Solutions

          • EventWatchAI
          • RiskShield
          • Multi-Tier Mapping
          • CommodityWatchAI
          • Supplier Assessment Library
        • Data Marketplace

          • Autonomous AI Mapping
          • Resilinc Disruption Vulnerability Index
          • R Score
          • Supplier Screening
          • Application Programming Interface (API)
        • Services

          • Advisory Services
          • Data and Intelligence Services
        • Elevate your Supply Chain Risk and Resiliency Program

          Schedule Demo
  • Use Cases
        • By Industry

          • Aerospace, Defense, Government
          • Automotive and Industrial
          • Healthcare & Life Sciences
          • High-Tech & Semiconductor
        • By Role

          • Supply Chain Risk & Resiliency Program Managers
        • By Business Need

          • Business Continuity Planning
          • Uyghur Forced Labor Prevention Act (UFLPA)
        • Elevate your Supply Chain Risk and Resiliency Program

          Schedule Demo
  • Resources
        • Learning Center

          • Blog
          • Case Studies
          • Event
          • On Demand Webinars
          • White Paper & Reports
        • Connect

          • Schedule Demo
          • Request Pricing
        • Special Reports

        • Special Report
        • Find valuable resources for managing supply chain disruptions in our Special Reports section.

        • Elevate your Supply Chain Risk and Resiliency Program

          Schedule Demo
  • Company
          • About Resilinc
          • Partners
          • Careers
          • Resilinc In the News
          • Press Releases
          • The Risk Game
        • Elevate your Supply Chain Risk and Resiliency Program

          Schedule Demo
  • Pricing
  • Contact
Login
Schedule Demo
Resilic Logo
  • Solutions
    • Solutions
      • EventWatchAI
      • RiskShield
      • Multi-Tier Mapping
      • CommodityWatchAI
      • Supplier Assessment Library
    • Data Marketplace
      • Autonomous AI Mapping
      • Resilinc Disruption Vulnerability Index
      • R Score
      • Supplier Screening
      • Application Programming Interface (API)
    • Services
      • Advisory Services
      • Data and Intelligence Services
  • Use Cases
    • By Industry
      • Aerospace, Defense, Government
      • Automotive & Industrial
      • Healthcare & Life Sciences
      • High-Tech & Semiconductor
    • By Role
      • Supply Chain Risk & Resiliency Program Managers
    • By Business Need
      • Business Continuity Planning
      • Uyghur Forced Labour Prevention Act (UFLPA)
  • Resources
    • Learning Center
      • Blog
      • Case Studies
      • Events
      • On Demand Webinars
      • White Papers & Reports
    • Connect
      • Schedule Demo
      • Request Pricing
    • Special Reports
  • Company
    • About Resilinc
    • Partners
    • Careers
    • Resilinc In the News
    • Press Releases
    • The Risk Game
  • Pricing
  • Contact
  • Login
  • Schedule Demo
Menu
  • Solutions
    • Solutions
      • EventWatchAI
      • RiskShield
      • Multi-Tier Mapping
      • CommodityWatchAI
      • Supplier Assessment Library
    • Data Marketplace
      • Autonomous AI Mapping
      • Resilinc Disruption Vulnerability Index
      • R Score
      • Supplier Screening
      • Application Programming Interface (API)
    • Services
      • Advisory Services
      • Data and Intelligence Services
  • Use Cases
    • By Industry
      • Aerospace, Defense, Government
      • Automotive & Industrial
      • Healthcare & Life Sciences
      • High-Tech & Semiconductor
    • By Role
      • Supply Chain Risk & Resiliency Program Managers
    • By Business Need
      • Business Continuity Planning
      • Uyghur Forced Labour Prevention Act (UFLPA)
  • Resources
    • Learning Center
      • Blog
      • Case Studies
      • Events
      • On Demand Webinars
      • White Papers & Reports
    • Connect
      • Schedule Demo
      • Request Pricing
    • Special Reports
  • Company
    • About Resilinc
    • Partners
    • Careers
    • Resilinc In the News
    • Press Releases
    • The Risk Game
  • Pricing
  • Contact
  • Login
  • Schedule Demo
  • Solutions
    • EventWatchAI
    • RiskShield
      • Supplier Assessment Library
      • Business Continuity Planning
    • Multi-Tier Mapping
      • Resilinc Supplier Network
    • Autonomous AI Mapping
    • CommodityWatchAI
    • Data Products and Offerings
    • Supply Chain Risk and Resiliency
      • Advisory Services
      • Data and Intelligence Services
  • Industry
    • Aerospace and Defense
    • Automotive & Industrial
    • Healthcare & Life Sciences
    • High-Tech & Semiconductor
  • Pricing
  • Resources
    • Learning Center
    • Special Reports
    • Events
    • Developer API
  • Company
    • About
    • Partners
    • News
  • Contact
  • Blog
  • Careers
  • Demo
  • Login
  • Customer Hub

Home / Blogs / A Different Take on Supply Chain Sweatshops

bangladesh supply chain factory fire

A Different Take on Supply Chain Sweatshops

Jul 23, 2015

Wayne Caccamo

Uncategorized

In a blog article I posted back on May 1, I rehashed John Oliver’s tirade on apparel industry supply chain practices. In a segment of his satirical HBO news commentary show “Last Week Tonight” that aired in May, he made a scathing indictment of the supply chain practices of the likes of H&M, Walmart, Nike, and the Gap. He essentially accused these brands of being negligent, or at best claiming to be clueless, about the exploitive and unsafe working conditions in places like India’s garment factories. I just came across a very interesting alternative view on this topic in a brief article in the July/August edition of Yale Alumni Magazine entitled “Sweatshops Opening the Door to Change” (Carole Bass, Yale College ’83; Yale Law ’97).

The article interviews Mushfiq Mobarak, an economist at the Yale School of Management, who argues that the explosive growth of India’s garment industry benefits girls and young women, who hold most of the sector’s 4 million jobs. The availability of factory jobs, he claims, is a significant reason why girls are staying in school longer and delaying marriage and childbirth.

At the same time, fatal factory fires and building collapse have killed over 1,000 workers in recent years, prompting calls for boycotts until conditions improve. Mobarak and Rachel Heath (Yale PND) postulate in a piece they co-authored for the Journal of Development Economics that boycotts are the wrong answer because factories have created the first job opportunities for Bangladeshi women. By comparing pre- and post-factory data in villages close to new factories and in more remote towns, the economists estimated the influence of the new jobs on choices about marriage and age at the birth of their first child.

Older girls might leave school to work in a factory. But, because employees who are literate and numerate draw higher paychecks, younger girls are staying in school longer, they found. “For the first time, it becomes worthwhile to invest in girls’ education,” Mubarak says.

Are the authors making a case for sweatshops, Bass asks? “It’s a case against the knee-jerk reaction that we need to stop importing from Bangladesh,” Mubarak responds. “The right policy response is not to ban imports, but to invest in factory safety.”

Indeed, according to the most recent Resilinc EventWatch™ Annual Report, factory fire was the number one cause of supply disruption events worldwide in 2014. An investment in corporate social responsibility programs and the monitoring of sub-tier factory safety and working conditions may be one of the best ways to manage both hidden supply disruption and continuity risk, as well brand risk. The first step in this approach is investing in supply chain event monitoring and supply chain visibility tools.

{{cta(‘ea62e25a-938b-40b5-b389-c7791c66c394’)}}

Resilinc Annual Report 2022 - Turbulence

Whitepaper

Cutting-edge Insights from Resilinc's Annual Report 2022

Be Prepared with the Latest Trends and Exclusive EventWatchAI Data to Step Up Your SCRM

Download Now

Recent Posts

How the UAW Strike is Shaking Up the Automotive Supply Chain

Rethinking Black Swan Events for Modern Supply Chain Risk Management

Q&A with 2023 Women in Supply Chain Winner Beth Cook

As the DSCSA Compliance Date Nears, are Pharmaceutical Supply Chains Ready?

Top 5 Aerospace Industry Supply Chain Disruptions of 2023

Panama Canal Drought: Lower Water Levels, Higher Supply Chain Risk

China’s Export Restrictions on Germanium and Gallium  

4 Ways to Develop a Demand-Responsive Supply Chain

About Resilinc

We’re the world’s leading supply chain monitoring, mapping, and resiliency solution. Over 100k organizations partner with us to take their SCRM programs from reactive to resilient.
Request Demo

Recent Blogs

Loading...
Oct 02, 2023
4 MIN READ
Resilinc Editorial Team

How the UAW Strike is Shaking Up the ...

September 29 Update on the UAW Strikes On Friday, the United Auto Workers (UAW) President,...
Automotive, Automotive Industry
An image of a black swan amongst a group of white swans
Sep 25, 2023
5 MIN READ
Resilinc Editorial Team

Rethinking Black Swan Events for Mode...

Black swan supply chain events have been traditionally associated with improbable, rare, or unlikely events...
Black swan supply chain events have been traditionally associated with improbable, rare, or unlikely events...
SCRM Best Practices, Supply chain management, Supply Chain Resilience
Q&A with Resilinc's Beth Cook 2023 Women in Supply Chain Winner
Sep 19, 2023
5 MIN READ
Resilinc Editorial Team

Q&A with 2023 Women in Supply Chain W...

Supply & Demand Chain Executive just announced the Women in Supply Chain award winners—and Resilinc’s...
Customer success, Supply chain management
Read All Blogs

Who's in your supply chain?

Better visibility starts now

Email Now|Call Now|Chat Now

Receive our monthly NewsWatch digest

Subscribe
Resilinc Logo

Most Trusted, Cognitive Supply Chain Risk Management Platform

Solutions

Blog

Careers

Company

  • About
  • News
  • Events
  • About
  • News
  • Events

Resources

  • White Papers & Reports
  • Case Studies
  • On-Demand Webinars
  • White Papers & Reports
  • Case Studies
  • On-Demand Webinars

Follows Us

Facebook-f Twitter Linkedin

Sales: [email protected]
Support: [email protected]
Partnerships: [email protected]

Resilinc Logo

Most Trusted, Cognitive Supply Chain Risk Management Platform

Company

  • About
  • News
  • Events
  • About
  • News
  • Events

Resources

  • White Papers & Reports
  • Case Studies
  • On-Demand Webinars
  • White Papers & Reports
  • Case Studies
  • On-Demand Webinars
  • Solutions
  • Blog
  • Careers
  • Solutions
  • Blog
  • Careers

Follows Us

Facebook-f Twitter Linkedin

Sales: [email protected]
Support: [email protected]
Partnerships: [email protected]

© 2023 Resilinc Corporation. All rights reserved.

Data Security

Privacy Policy

Can Reshoring Stabilize the Semiconductor Supply Chain?

Learn more in our in-depth report about disruptions impacting reshoring growth, the semiconductor workforce gap, and actionable risk mitigation strategies.

           Download Now